Leather vs Synthetic: The Difference After Years of Use

• Leather (The "Gamer"): A high-quality leather does not degrade; it evolves. Over years of play, it develops a rich patina, softens to mold perfectly to the player's hand, and retains its structural integrity. While laces may need replacing, the shell itself often becomes more comfortable and functional, maintaining that "pop".

• Synthetic (The "Floppy" Pancake): In contrast, synthetic gloves (often made of mesh or faux leather) tend to lose their shape entirely, becoming "floppy" or "pancaked." Because the material lacks the fibrous strength of hide, it cannot hold a formed pocket for long. Over time, the surface often cracks, peels, or tears rather than breaking in. As pros have noted, once a synthetic glove is broken in, "the shape didn't hold very long".

Verdict: Leather creates a legacy; synthetic creates landfill.